go-v.orgdoi

Retention Versus Removal of Osteosynthesis Material in Fracture-Related Infections: Clinical Criteria, Mechanical Stability, and Treatment Outcomes

Andrés Ricardo Arévalo Sánchez · IECCMEXICO · 2026

  • DOI 10.64784/355
  • Publisher OpenAlex
  • Type article
  • Issued 2026

Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.

IECCMEXICO · OpenAlex · article · 2026

Abstract

Fracture-related infection represents a complex complication of orthopedic trauma in which infection control must be achieved without compromising the mechanical conditions required for fracture healing. This study analyzed implant retention versus removal or exchange of osteosynthesis material, focusing on clinical criteria, mechanical stability, fracture-healing status, microbiological factors, and treatment outcomes.

A structured comparative review of the scientific literature was conducted using the Scientific Method, incorporating evidence on debridement, antimicrobial therapy, and implant retention, as well as implant removal, exchange to new internal fixation, and conversion to external fixation. The reviewed evidence showed that implant retention can achieve favorable outcomes when fixation remains stable, fracture reduction is satisfactory, adequate debridement is feasible, soft tissues are viable, and fracture union remains achievable.

In contrast, implant loosening, mechanical failure, loss of reduction, infected nonunion, inadequate source control, or completed fracture consolidation favor implant removal or exchange. Reported treatment failure was higher after DAIR than after internal or external fixation exchange in some cohorts; however, these differences were influenced by patient selection and should not be interpreted as evidence of universal superiority of revision strategies. Infection eradication and fracture union were achieved in approximately 86% of patients in a large multicenter cohort, highlighting the importance of evaluating both infectious and mechanical outcomes.

Infection duration influenced DAIR success but did not function as an absolute criterion for implant removal. Overall, treatment success depends on individualized integration of infection biology, mechanical stability, fracture-healing potential, soft-tissue condition, and surgical source control. The optimal strategy is therefore the one that achieves durable infection control while preserving or restoring the mechanical environment required for definitive fracture union and functional recovery.

Open the resolved locator · 10.64784/355

Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)