go-v.orgdoi

Constituting Hurricane Communities for Disaster Response: Repurposing Survey Responses to Maximize Safety for All Publics

Sonny Patel · container not stated · 2026

  • DOI 10.57709/407
  • Publisher OpenAlex
  • Type dissertation
  • Issued 2026

Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.

· OpenAlex · dissertation · 2026

Abstract

Conventional hazard frameworks, like Protective Action Decision Model, treat the public as a pre-existing demographic aggregate that rationally processes risk information. However, technically sound warnings routinely fail to produce uniform evacuation behavior, particularly among marginalized and access-constrained populations. This dissertation resolves that paradox by operationalizing Charland’s (1987) theory of constitutive rhetoric at population scale, demonstrating that disaster communication does not merely inform a static public but actively constitutes publics through: hailing, transhistorical subjectivity, and illusion of freedom.

Using a computational text-as-data pipeline, including Louvain community detection, this study identifies seven discursive communities from a three-storm corpus spanning Hurricanes Laura, Sally, and Ian: Preparedness & Fortify, Forecast & Uncertainty, Information Ecology, Post Impacts, Access & Pets, Surge & Landuse, and Evacuation Governance. These communities share hurricane exposure yet inhabit sharply different narrative and aesthetic worlds. Within the dissertation’s Hurricane Ian subsample (N=725), evacuation zones, housing type, and media channels significantly sorted residents into these communities (p<.05).

Residents with a pre-existing evacuation plan or sandbags were nearly twice as likely to evacuate as those without, while generator owners were roughly 37% less likely to evacuate (p<.05). Even holding resources and demographics constant, Post Impacts members were half as likely to evacuate as Evacuation Governance members (p<.01). Staying was narrated as triumphant for well- resourced communities like Preparedness & Fortify, but as a constrained compromise for others like Access & Pets and Post Impacts. These findings illuminate an overlooked source of evacuation failure.

Where conventional models treat non-evacuation as a cognition problem to be fixed with clearer warnings, this dissertation shows that publics are already constituted, resourced, and narratively locked in place before any warning arrives. Theoretically, this study expands constitutive rhetoric beyond elite-authored texts to the infrastructural and material artifacts of everyday disaster life, and shows that publics and counterpublics can be detected quantitatively at scale. Methodologically, it demonstrates that rapid-assessment surveys can be repurposed as primary constitutive data through a replicable pipeline linking unsupervised text analysis to regression modeling.

For a field built around a single, persuadable public, this dissertation offers the tools to see, and design for, the publics that exist.

Open the resolved locator · 10.57709/407

Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)

Registry
OpenAlex DOI index + API
Fetched
2026-11-20 17:48 UTC
Cache state
not cached yet (bulk-index+openalex)
Locator
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14694/16618
Metadata licence
OpenAlex metadata (CC0)
Scope
Metadata as returned by the resolver; abstracts are never generated here.