Comparison Of The Sensitivity, Precision And Reproducibility Of The Multi-test Device And Blood Lancet
B. Topuz · The Internet Journal of Dermatology · 2001
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
The Internet Journal of Dermatology · OpenAlex · article · 2001
Abstract
Background:In studies using allergen extracts, patients with 1+ reactions had been usually excluded.However, the borderline allergen reactions may give false positive or false negative results, in respect to chosen cutoff point.Objective: This study aimed to compare the skin prick test device Multi-Test applicator with blood lancet, in respect to their sensitivity, precision and reproducibility.Methods: The first group consist of 14 healthy subjects.The second group consist of 14 patients with allergic rhinitis, recruited from the Out-patient Allergy Clinic.The patients had known sensitivity to at least one allergen.Skin prick tests were performed with the single blood lancet and the Multi-Test device.The solutions used for testing were histamine, negative control for both group, and allergens (Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus, Dermatophagoides pharinae, grass, tree, weed, epidermal) for the second group.Results: For all three tested solutions, mean wheal sizes were larger for the Multi-Test device than for the lancet, in healthy group(p<0.0001)and in allergic rhinitis group(P<0.001).The coefficients of variations for Multi-Test device were always lower than lancet.(Multi Test vs. lancet; for negative control: 49.81 vs 76.74, for histamine: 23.36 vs 36.76, for allergens: 79.60 vs.
100.56).If 3 mm was chosen as a cutoff point 22.9 % of the reactions were false positive for Multi-Test device.Conclusions: According to results of our study cutoff point of 4.5 mm for Multi-Test device was comparable with cutoff point of 3 mm for lancet, with no false positive reactions for both devices.
Open the resolved locator · 10.5580/561
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)