Effective Legislation Producing Realized Health Services
— · The Internet Journal of Emergency Medicine · 2004
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
The Internet Journal of Emergency Medicine · OpenAlex · article · 2004
Abstract
Public Law 104-166, more commonly known as the Traumatic Brain Injury Act of 1996 serves as a critical first step from a legislative perspective, in assuring that brain injuries are fully understood and treated in both an acute clinical environment and in the public health arena. And, through this discussion and research it will foster the discussion needed to understand its underlying causes, its overlying costs, and what can be done to prevent such tragic occurrences that affect the lives of so many Americans. This discussion analyzes the mechanisms and processes that were essential in the making of Public Law 104-166 through the legislative process.
As with any law or rule, it is fundamental to understand whom it affects, and what it addresses, as well as the significance of the problem it attempts to influence.
TRAUMATIC BRAIN INJURY (TBI) The incidence of traumatic brain injury in the United States consists of about one million people who are treated and released from hospital emergency centers, 230,000 people who are hospitalized and survive, and 50,000 people who die.1 The incidence rate of TBI (combined hospitalization and mortality rate) is 95 per 100,000 population, where 22% of those who suffer a TBI eventually die from their injury.1 Risk of TBI is highest among adolescents, young adults, and people older than 75 years of age.1 Leading causes of TBI include motor vehicle accidents, violence, and falls, though this varies by age where falls account as the leading cause in people 65 years of age or over, and transportation leads for people aged 5 to 64 years.1 Every year 80,000 Americans survive a TBI and are released from the hospital with a TBIrelated disability, at last estimate there are 5.3 million Americans living with a TBI disability.1 TBI related injuries may result in impairment of: (1) cognitive abilities such as concentration, memory, judgement, and mood; (2) movement abilities including strength, coordination, and balance; (3) sensations such as tactile and special senses such as vision.1 There is limited available in terms of total monetary cost analysis of TBI in addition to the immeasurable cost borne by those suffering from TBI and the friends and family who must provide daily support.
A 1985 study showed the total cost as $37.8 billion by combining direct annual expenditures of $4.5 billion and indirect annual costs of $33.3 billion.1 The National Center for Injury Prevention and Control (NCIPC) provides the following guidelines in its dealing with TBI as a public health problem1: Ongoing surveillance to follow trends in the incidence, risk factors, causes, and outcomes of these injuries through its Guidelines for the Surveillance of Central Nervous System Injury, a publication that sets forth standards and recommendations to improve coordination of central nervous system injury surveillance.
The development of effective, science-based strategies to prevent the occurrence of these injuries. The development of more effective strategies to improve the outcomes of these injuries and minimize disability among those injured.
In the NCIPC's 1999 report to the United States Congress it defined TBI as: an occurrence of injury to the head that is documented in a medical record, with one or more of the following conditions attributed to head injury: observed or self-reported decreased Effective Legislation Producing Realized Health Services 2 of 7 level of consciousness, amnesia, skull fracture, objective neurological or neuropsychological abnormality, or diagnosed intracranial lesion; or as an occurrence of death resulting from trauma, with head injury listed on the death certificate, autopsy report, or medical examiner's report in the sequence of conditions that resulted in death.2 THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS The legislative process is a complex multi-step and multitiered system of creating law.
There are generally four methods in which Congress can initiate legislation: bills, joint resolutions, concurrent resolutions, and simple resolutions.3 Bills are the common form that most legislation is initiated with. Bills originating in the House of Representatives are designated by the letters “H.R.” and are followed by an identifying number that remains with it through the legislative process. Bills originating in the Senate begin with an “S.” and are also followed by an identifying number. Bills are presented to the President when they are approved in identical form by both the House of Representatives and Senate.
Joint resolutions have little practical difference from a bill and can begin in either the House of Representatives or in the Senate.3 Joint resolutions originating in the House of Representatives are indicated by “H.J.Res.” followed by its identifying number, and those originating in the Senate are indicated by “S.J.Res.” followed by its identifying number. Concurrent resolutions deal with the operations of both the House of Representatives and Senate.3 Concurrent resolutions originating in the House of Representatives are indicated by “H.Con.Res.” followed by its identifying number, and in the Senate by “S.Con.Res.” followed by its identifying number.
On approval by both chambers of the Congress, a concurrent resolution is then signed by the Clerk of the House and the Secretary of the Senate, it does not require Presidential action.3 If a matter deals with only one chamber of Congress, then it is referred to as a simple resolution, and are designated by “H.Res.” and “S.Res” followed by their identifying number in the House of Representatives and the Senate, respectively.
After a bill is introduced by a member of Congress, and provided it meets various requirements such as signature of the sponsor, as well as signatures of any co-sponsors (it is not necessary for a bill to have co-sponsors), the bill is assigned its legislative number and referred to the appropriate committee.3 The committee phase of legislation is one of the most critical stages of the legislative process. It is an opportunity for open discussion on the matter.
The first step by a committee is to hold a public hearing, where a committee can engage in discussion with witnesses representing various viewpoints on the bill.3 The committee will announce the date, place, and subject of any hearing it holds on pending legislation.3 Upon the completion of hearings, a bill is then considered in a session referred to as a “mark-up.”3 The committee examines the evidence, viewpoints, and other information it has gathered and can then offer amendments to the bill, with the whole committee then voting whether to accept or reject these changes.3 These mark-up sessions may happen at the subcommittee or full committee level, or both.
At the conclusion of a committee session on a particular bill, one of three things may happen: the bill can be reported as-is, reported with amendments, or tabled, which would mean that no further action would be taken on the bill.3 A fourth possibility is a “clean bill,” these are usually reported when there are extensive amendments to a proposed bill where it would be better presented in a new format, these bills would receive a new identifying number.3 A Committee Report is drawn up if the committee decides to report the bill, this report would explain the purpose of the bill along with reasons as to its approval. The next step is floor consideration of a bill.
This can be a simple or complex operation that is dictated by what “rules” of debate are adopted for the consideration of a specific bill.3 Debate time is usually divided between proponents and opponents, and amendments may also be debated on and voted upon.3 After the debate stage has concluded, the bill goes for final passage, unless some opposition is able to vote to “recommit” where a bill is returned to the committee for further modification.3 Both the House of Representatives and the Senate follow special and distinct rules in parliamentary procedure for floor consideration of a bill.
It is suffice to say, that the general explanation above is satisfactory in understanding the general process for floor consideration. After a measure is passed in either chamber of Congress, it is sent to the other chamber for consideration.
A bill must pass both chambers in the exact same form before it can be presented to the President for signature into law.3 If the Senate changes any aspect of the legislation, it is returned to the House for concurrence, or a conference committee may be drawn up consisting of both members of the House and Senate to work out the differences in committee.3 Effective Legislation Producing Realized Health Services 3 of 7 The final step is a vote for final passage.
In the House of Representatives this may be done by recorded electronic vote where individual votes are registered or by a voice vote and no record of individual responses is made.3 The Senate does not use electronic voting mechanisms, and votes are Yea/Nay votes by voice and are registered in the record.3 After a measure has been passed, it is considered “enrolled” and is then sent to the President who can sign it into law, veto it, let it become law without his signature, or at the end of a session, pocket-veto it.3 The summary of the legislative process is presented to provide context for better understanding how and why certain matters are enacted into law and others become lost in the abyss of theoretical policy.
It is important to recognize that the above schema of the legislative process does not take into consideration the full political scope and mechanism under which legislators must work under to effectively carry a piece of legislation from introduction to enactment into law. Nevertheless, with a contextual framework, it provides for a better opportunity to parse legislation affecting public health concerns in a manner that can make legislative efforts on the part of health care professionals more effective.
Open the resolved locator · 10.5580/430
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)