go-v.orgdoi

Reimagining Arts-Centered Inquiry in Schools as Pragmatic Instrumentalism

Leann F. Logsdon, Deron R. Boyles · Philosophy of education · 2012

  • DOI 10.47925/2012.405
  • Publisher Philosophy of Education Society
  • Type article
  • Issued 2012

Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.

Philosophy of education · Philosophy of Education Society · article · 2012

Abstract

Arts education advocates have argued for years that the arts deserve a place in the public school curriculum alongside other disciplines. The rationales to support the place of the arts, however, suffer from the kind of utilitarianism that subordinates inquiry to goals and objectives aligned with efficiency and production. The arts, on this view, are useful because they produce students with skills that will be beneficial to their future lives in the work force. This essay argues that the discourse of utility is an important problem to challenge and suggests that pragmatic instrumentalism is a better way to advocate for the arts.

This is so, in part, because the practice of pragmatic instrumentalism differs from utilitarianism in that utilitarian rationales offered by arts advocates (in an effort to convince policymakers and arts educators of the positive role the arts can play in achieving societal goals) not only lack empirical support but represent a dualistic conceptualization inadequate to the task of understanding how students make meaning when engaged in arts-centered inquiry. This essay begins with John Dewey's view that knowing is not self-enclosed and final but is to reconstruction of situations 1 to propose an expanded conceptualization of arts-centered inquiry as pragmatic instrumentalism.

Moreover, we see a critical need to interrogate the current advocacy claim that arts education develops the creativity and innovation necessary to maintain the nation's global competitiveness. We draw a distinction between the syntactical use of the term instrumental in denoting structural, utilitarian justifications for the arts and the more expansive conceptual application of the term, which encompasses benefits that the arts provide individual students in mediating complex and connected learning. The difference has to do with the center of power. Structural, utilitarian instrumen- tality has as its intended outcome efficient management of human behavior.

By contrast, pragmatic instrumentalism looks at transformative consequences for particular individuals engaged in practical, everyday transactions. By reclaiming the term instrumental for arts-centered inquiry, we seek to restore the notion of generativity to arts learning and critique current efforts to reduce artistry to utilitarian means for developing creativity and innovation in and for students. RECONCEPTUALIZING INSTRUMENTALISM IN ARTS EDUCATION Dewey's work to reconstruct the concept of instrumentalism pragmatically reflects his time and place.

Noting the industrial accomplishments and scientific achievements of his day, Dewey nevertheless considers both to be inadequate in addressing the challenges confronting the world. He writes:

Open the resolved locator · 10.47925/2012.405

Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)