Practical Knowledge and the Fiction of Professionalism
Chris Higgins · Philosophy of education · 2012
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
Philosophy of education · OpenAlex · article · 2012
Abstract
In “Promoting Dialogue on Teacher Professionalism,” Jeannie Kerr argues that the longstanding and recently increasing heteronomy of teaching is due to a misconception about teacher knowledge. According to Kerr (following Richard Bernstein and the hermeneutic line generally), modern epistemology is plagued by a dichotomy “between objectivism and relativism,” leaving us no good way to talk about (among other things) practical wisdom. The idea is that professional practice centrally involves judgment, understood as the intelligent linking of sound generalizations with genuine features of novel, concrete, messy situations. Here knowing and doing come together.
As the terms “intelligent,” “sound,” and “genuine” are meant to indicate, the practitioner is trying to get things right. At the same time, getting things right cannot mean abstracting away from the purposive engagement of the practitioner, for it is only within the frame of such engagement that salient features of the novel situation become so. Such a view of practical knowledge is incompatible both with subjectivism (on which view it makes no sense to speak of getting things right) and objectivism (which seeks a description of states of affairs that minimizes the irreducible features of situations and stands independent of our purposes).
Open the resolved locator · 10.47925/2012.376
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)