A Comparative Analysis of the Evolution of Industrial Policies in Korea and Japan since the 1980s: Focusing on Developmental State Theory and Historical Institutionalism
Jin Hee Bae, Hee Jae Kim, Byung Joo Min · container not stated · 2026
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
· OpenAlex · article · 2026
Abstract
Purpose: This study aims to conduct a comparative analysis of the evolution of industrial policies in South Korea and Japan since the 1980s through an institutionalist lens. It examines how both nations' state-led developmental models diverged in response to shifting environments following Korea’s 1986 “Industrial Development Act,” and derives a new strategic role for the state and provides policy implications suited for the current era of U.S.-China technological hegemony and economic security.
Design/methodology/approach: Utilizing a dual analytical framework combining Developmental State Theory and Historical Institutionalism, the study analyzes the formation, maintenance, and transformation of institutions through path dependency and critical junctures, focusing on Korea’s MOTIR and Japan’s METI (including predecessors). Findings: The findings reveal that while Korea and Japan started from similar developmental state models in the 1980s, they experienced distinct institutional divergences.
After the 1997 financial crisis, Korea embraced neoliberal reforms while evolving its developmental substance through “conversion” and “layering,” repurposing existing capacities for new objectives. Japan maintained path-dependent, incremental change, recently reactivating past policy legacies amid economic security concerns. Rather than dismantling industrial policy, both sustained their role as “transformative developmental states” through differing evolutionary paths.
Practical implications: In the current era of economic security, the state must move beyond a unilateral director to become a “builder of public-private collaborative networks” and a “pivot for industrial ecosystems” fostering strategic high-tech industries (e.g., semiconductors, AI). Korea should maintain flexible responsiveness to external shocks while referencing Japan’s industry-academia-government innovation ecosystems. Originality/value: This research overcomes the limitations of previous studies focused on specific periods or sectors by providing a long-term, diachronic comparative analysis from 1986 to the present.
By supplementing the static limitations of Developmental State Theory with Historical Institutionalism, this study multidimensionally elucidates the reality of the evolving state role that persists despite neoliberal globalization, thereby offering a theoretical foundation for the “return of industrial policy.”
Open the resolved locator · 10.46396/kjem..111.1
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)