Journal of Education & Social Policy
— · Journal of Education & Social Policy · 2018
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
Journal of Education & Social Policy · Center for Promoting Ideas · paratext · 2018
Abstract
Postgraduate trainee teachers undergo profound 'shifts' in their pedagogical understanding and practices through the year that they are taught at a UK Higher Education Institution.This study 'investigated, in a paired pre-post design, the espoused pedagogical beliefs of three cohorts of PGCE trainees, at two time pointsat the onset and toward the end of their studies in a teacher education department in a major HEI in the UK, with corroborative results from a fourth cohort and from a wider set of institutions.Using an adaptation of the 'practices' scale of Swan (2006), trainees' pedagogical beliefs were charted and described on a continuum running from transmissionist to child-centred through answering 25 items, and shifts from pre-course to post course were investigated on two frontsindividually and for each item.Two general principles are represented in the data: trainees seem to either make rather more radical shifts towards child-centeredness (75/117 trainees [64.1%] at an average shift of +0.28) or more slight shifts towards a more teacher centred orientation (37/117 trainees [31.6%] at an average shift of -0.18.The average shift was +0.14 per trainee (from 3.35 to 3.49) -a significant trend towards a greater learner-centrism across the longitudinal study.I am currently studying the pedagogical beliefs of pre-and post-course postgraduate student teachers on the postgraduate Certificate of Education courses, which enable them to teach in the UK; charting shifts in these beliefs (Clarke and Hollingsworth, 2002) to try and understand the key levers for change (Smith, 2012).The beliefs under analysis are communicated through responses to questionnaires given on the day the trainees first arrive at University and again on the final day of the course.The questionnaires consist of 25 statements on English primary teaching practices in which the participants had to express a "belief" (scored 1 to 5).Analysis of each trainee"s cumulative responses places them on a continuum similar to that constructed by Pampaka et al., following the "practices scale" of Swan (2006).This continuum runs from teacher-centred to child-centred, based on the central concept of the "very common distinction" (Pampaka et al., 2008 p3) between didactic teaching models (which they call "teacher-centric") which can be seen as transmissionist, or instructionist (Harel and Papert, 1991; cf.Schuh, 2004), and the "learning-centric" model where the focus is on students creating their own learning through the facilitation of the teacher rather than being directly taught (Smith, 2013).The aim is to chart the espoused beliefs of the trainees over the course of the year: whether the trainees leave with the same, similar or altered beliefs from those they arrived with.A key problem with the issue of measuring teachers" beliefs is discriminating and differentiating between genuine beliefs and stated beliefs.Teachersespecially at the preservice stagemay erroneously assert that they hold certain beliefs because they think the researchers may want to hear these, or because they are in current vogue, or even pedagogies that they believe they are practising when they are not (Vacc and Bright, 1999;Wilson and Cooney, 2002).Espoused beliefs should not therefore be considered as predictors of genuine classroom practice.They are not necessarily deliberately disingenuous, but may be considered as representative of intentions rather than actions (Feiman-Nemseret al., 1987;Fosnot, 1989).These intentions may not suit a reality which bears little or no resemblance to the envisioned situation and experiences for which the original intentions were created
Open the resolved locator · 10.30845/jesp
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)