go-v.orgdoi

The Role of the Arts in Extending and Challenging the Boundaries of History Education

Avner Segall · Canadian Social Studies · 2021

  • DOI 10.29173/css19
  • Publisher University of Alberta Library
  • Type book-review
  • Issued 2021

Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.

Canadian Social Studies · University of Alberta Library · book-review · 2021

Abstract

As those of us in the area of history education well know, though often find it convenient to forget, students-actually, most of us-learn just as much about the past from the arts than from sources normally used in the history classroom.Indeed, we probably learn more, and more powerfully, for example, about the French Rebellion of 1832 from Victor Hugo's Les Misérables (or its contemporary musical or cinematic versions) or about the Spanish Civil War from Picasso's Guernica than what is taught in school.Similarly, the spirit of the Renaissance and its ideas are more viscerally conveyed-and are impressed upon us in more meaningful and evocative ways-through the paintings and frescoes of Michelangelo, Raphael, Ghirlandaio, and Gozzoli (especially his Procession of the Magi in Florence's Palazzo Medici Riccardi), in the statues of Donatello, or through the clean, rational lines of the architecture of Brunelleschi, than a textbook or classroom lecture ever could.And yet, as teachers, we still, too often, tend to ignore or devalue the significant pedagogical power of these artistic forms and their ability to invoke insight into the past and its people, ones that resonates with us, that invite us to understand, identify, empathize, and wonder.When we do include aesthetic texts in the curriculum, we often do so to highlight their otherness from history-their fictive nature and historical inaccuracy-and, thus, dismiss or "correct" them.There is, it seems, a prevailing assumption among many history educators, as Terrie Epstein (1994a) noted, "that when secondary students encounter the arts in historical contexts, they partake in educational activities that at worst represent a descent into frill or fantasy or at best promote the cultivation of creative, but not academically credible, thoughts or experiences" (p.174).Regrettably, as my own visits to history classrooms indicate, not much has changed in that regard since Epstein wrote this more than a quarter of a century ago.This is not to suggest that the role of the arts-and the promotion of using the arts in history classrooms-has not been explored in the academic literature.In fact, in the last three

Open the resolved locator · 10.29173/css19

Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)