go-v.orgdoi

Universal Suffrage and Direct Democracy

Brigitte Studer · GenderOpen - Repositorium für die Geschlechterforschung · 2003

  • DOI 10.25595/403
  • Publisher OpenAlex
  • Type reference-entry
  • Issued 2003

Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.

GenderOpen - Repositorium für die Geschlechterforschung · OpenAlex · reference-entry · 2003

Abstract

IN THE AREA OF political rights, Switzerland undeniably stands out as a unique case.It was the first modem democracy to grant universal male suffrage in 1848, and while this right remained unquestioned, Switzerland was also the last country in Europe to grant the right to vote to its female citizens.Women's suffrage did not receive approval at the national level until 1971.Moreover, it was not until 1990 that every political body at the cantonal and municipal level finally recognized women's voting rights, and this only because the canton of Appenzell Innerhoden was forced to capitulate in the face of a decision handed down by the federal court.All told, close to one hundred votes had been needed for the measure to pass electorally.How should we interpret Switzerland's exceptionalisrn in this matter?For the persistence of its refusal to grant women's suffrage was certainly an anomaly, even though women's political representation in Switzerland quickly caught up with European averages after 1990.Any analysis of the question must obviously take into account the specificity of the Swiss political system, particularly its founding principles of federalism and direct democracy.Swiss direct democracy incorporates two unusual features, both of them independent of the founding of the federal state in 1848.First, there was an old democratic tradition known as the Landsgemeinde, which periodically assembled all citizens eligible to vote.Political theorists of liberalism in 1848 had been highly critical of this form of democracy (which predated the founding of the federal state in certain rural regions), arguing that it did not provide the appropriate mechanisms to control the exercise of political power.Dian Schefold has shown that as a result of this criticism, liberal theorists opted instead for a mode of representational democracy, which was the model for the new Swiss confederation (see Schefold).Nonetheless, the form of federalism adopted allowed the Landsgemeinde to subsist in some cantons of central Switzerland.Second, there are the two mechanisms that specifically define Swiss direct----or, more accurately, sernidirect-dernocracy, namely, the citizens' right of referendum and their right to introduce constitutional amendments by a citizen's initiative.These rights were introduced later, in 1874 and 1891, respectively.Thus, women's exclusion from the political process was determined prior to the implementation of the rights granting ordinary Swiss citizens the means to participate directly in government through their ability to introduce their own particular interests into the shaping of the general will.These circumstances limit the relevance of the main argument in the debate about women's suffrage in Switzerland, that is, the notably participatory nature of Swiss citizenship and the extent of Swiss democratic rights.The latter issue must therefore be put into historical perspective.While it is true that the rights to referendum and to introduce citizens' initiatives have weighed heavily in the denial of women's suffrage during the 20th century, this was not true in the 19th century.In fact, while the committee of the Diet charged with drafting the constitution of 1848 was concerned at the time about the political inequality reserved for Jews (only to comply with it in the end), not one word was ever uttered about women's legal rights.By instituting a system of universal male suffrage, the liberals of 1848 were guided by a premise that

Open the resolved locator · 10.25595/403

Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)

Registry
OpenAlex DOI index + API
Fetched
2026-11-20 08:05 UTC
Cache state
not cached yet (bulk-index+openalex)
Locator
https://www.genderopen.de/25595/408
Metadata licence
OpenAlex metadata (CC0)
Scope
Metadata as returned by the resolver; abstracts are never generated here.