The Cyborg, its Manifesto and their relevance today: Some reflections
Zoë Sofoulis · GenderOpen - Repositorium für die Geschlechterforschung · 2015
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
GenderOpen - Repositorium für die Geschlechterforschung · OpenAlex · article · 2015
Abstract
Squirming Back into the Cyborg ManifestoThe mere presence of adoring fans has been insufficient to entice Donna Haraway to visit Australia.Only Helen Verran and postgraduates at Melbourne University's History and Philosophy of Science department managed to interest her once in the late 1990s.So as the first Australian with a doctorate co-supervised by Haraway at the History of Consciousness program at the University of California, Santa Cruz, I have occasionally been called upon to speak when the doyenne of cyborg feminism was, as usual, unavailable down under (Sofoulis 2003).The role of antipodean Haraway always made me uneasy.It is a mistake to project patriarchal (and oedipal) traditions of scholarly filiation onto feminists.In my observation, feminist supervisors rarely seek to turn out clones of themselves and feminist students do not usually aspire to replicate/replace their professors.Like cyborgs, feminist students can be "exceedingly unfaithful to" and quite uninterested in their origins (Haraway, 1991, p.151) .1 But what really makes me squirm whenever I read the opening pages of the Manifesto or am asked to speak for its author, is how closely I recognise my (then) self in the feminist, and especially ecofeminist, tendencies that Haraway was railing against.In the four-part conference presentation where Haraway introduced her cyborg to US audiences, I went first because my view was more standard and even "retro" compared to where Donna wanted to take us.For I was one of those feminists reproducing all those dualisms of "white capitalist patriarchy"; I was on about the woman-nature / man-machine connections and angsting over the inevitability of C 3 I and the military logics of computing leading to the Star Wars apocalypse (Sofia, 1984).I wrote about "bisexuality, pre-oedipal symbiosis … other seductions to organic wholeness" (150).With typical postgraduate self-centredness, I paid little attention to Haraway's cyborg while working on my own ambiguous metaphors and myths of high technology and science fiction like the brain-womb, the spermatic word, the penis-breast, the cannibaleye (Sofia, 1987).The bisexual / combined parent figure of the Uroborous, the serpent that feeds and fertilises itself, was one of my favoured metaphors that made Donna want to "regurgitate'".I saw Frankenstein's monster and the cyborg as equivalent technosex fantasies, whereas Haraway placed them on different sides of her chart contrasting the logics of "white capitalist patriarchy" with those of "the informatics of domination".Haraway's closely related later essay "Situated Knowledges" (1988; 1991) generously notes it was revised in relation to my doctoral work on the metaphorics of vision in scientific discovery.What she doesn't say was that again, I was articulating the kind of position and interpretation that she was critiquing and improving upon.In short, I was pre-Harawayan and Haraway was post-Sofoulis .
2 "The machine is us, our processes, an aspect of our embodiment."(180) Eventually I found my way back to Haraway, via Latour et al.'s actor-network theory and especially Don Ihde's phenomenology of technology (Ihde, 1990), introduced to me by my (then) postgraduate, Ingrid Richardson (2003, 2007).Playing "Donna Down Under" had forced me to reengage with Haraway's work.I had arrived at the History of Consciousness program already interested in the mythic aspects of All page references are to the version of 'A Cyborg Manifesto' in Haraway, 1991.
1 Our disagreements were merely theoretical.Personally and professionally, Donna has been unfailingly conscientious, supportive, 2 generous, inspiring and congenial.
Open the resolved locator · 10.25595/115
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)