Effects of microstructural parameters and abrasive environment on sliding abrasion of single-reinforced and dual-reinforced white cast irons
E. Demirer · The University of Queensland · 2021
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
The University of Queensland · The University of Queensland · dissertation · 2021
Abstract
In mining and materials handling industries, transfer chutes are widely used to guide material flow between conveyors. Transfer chutes are exposed to wear as a result of interaction with thousands of tons of material being processed. Sacrificial wear liners, made of materials such as martensitic steels, white cast irons or ceramics are used to protect chute walls against wear. Wear liners require maintenance which are very costly interruptions to plant operations. Reducing both frequency and duration of maintenance stoppages through improving performance of wear resisting materials is vitally important.High chromium white cast iron (HCWCI) is the particular interest of this research.
The systematic response of HCWCI in an industrially realistic laboratory testing environment needs to be determined as the benchmark for further progress. HCWCI microstructure are a combination of a relatively soft metallic matrix (with a hardness range of 500-800 HV) similar to martensitic steels and a continuous network of hard Cr-rich carbides (in particular M7C3 carbides in this research with a hardness range of 1300–1600 HV). In low stress sliding bed abrasion (LSSA) condition, occurring in transfer chutes, the superior performance of HCWCI compared to martensitic steel is attributed to this composite structure.
However, the ore types with high quartz content are capable of wearing M7C3, diminishing the superiority of alloys which rely on this constituent. Adding a second type of carbide (with a hardness range of about 1600–2800 HV, significantly harder than M7C3) into the microstructure of HCWCI has been proposed to improve their wear performance (dual-reinforcement hypothesis). A primary aim of this research is to determine the effects of macro additions of MC type carbide (in particular NbC - niobium carbide) to HCWCI.
To distinguish the conventional HCWCI from the dual-reinforced counterparts, the conventional HCWCI is denoted as single-reinforced in this research.Previous research on performance assessments of both single- and dual-reinforced HCWCI have generally relied upon standard laboratory abrasion testing, which has been criticised for providing unreliable results compared to field trials and for replicating an artificial wear system. Wear resistance is not an intrinsic material property but rather a system parameter, therefore, laboratory performance assessments must emulate the actual wear system as accurately as possible.
Previous research has generally compared the host (original HCWCI before carbide former addition) performance to that of the alloy after dual-reinforcement obtained by adding elemental carbide forming metals, without paying much attention to the change that this causes in the host alloy, notably in the M7C3 carbide fraction. There has not been a standard wear-performance assessment criterion followed. In this PhD thesis project, the abrasion performances of single- and dual-reinforced HCWCI are examined using a new and industrially realistic testing method, denoted as ICAT (inner circumference abrasion test).
Being a new abrasion test, correlating the ICAT to a relevant field trial was an important consideration. Such correlation has been performed successfully, despite the field trial data being subject to some ambiguities. The ICAT is very versatile, permitting simulation of a broad range of industrial conditions. The experimental regime used in this project includes three series of sliding abrasion conditions, using a variety of abrasive types (basalt, greywacke and granite), trialling different particle sizes, and varying particle impingement angles.
The project intends not only to obtain reliable laboratory test data correlating well to field trials in low-stress sliding-bed abrasion, but also to assess the possibility of improvements in dual-reinforcement following consistent methods. The quantitative results from the testing regime are then compared with qualitative observations of worn surface features (by scanning electron microscopy examination) throughout the research. This SEM examination permits identification of the micro-mechanisms of wear and damage which can provide explanations for the quantitative trends.To ensure reliable and industrially realistic test results, 17 single-reinforced HCWCI alloys are tested.
The first stage testing is to examine alloys in different abrasive types. The best wear performance provided by these HCWCIs (compared to homogeneous steels) is found in the basalt tests, followed by the greywacke and the granite. All tests show superior wear performance from HCWCI compared to the reference steel Bisalloy500 (used to calculate relative life RL). The greywacke and granite tests report steadily increasing RLs for increasing carbide volume fraction (CVF).
For the basalt tests, the trend starts as increasing RL for increasing CVF, at low CVF, but the trend later reaches a plateau (at maximum RL and optimum CVF point), and then changes to a reducing RL for increasing CVF beyond the optimum. This trend is termed as “RL reversal phenomenon”. The RL reversal phenomenon is believed to result from two factors, (i) fine-size abrasive particle presence to cause preferential abrasion and (ii) a mild abrasive hardness to generate high differential abrasion rates for the microstructural constituents. If either of these two factors is absent, the RL reversal phenomenon is not observed.
This is demonstrated, for example, by the coarse-particle basalt experiments carried out as the second stage.In the third stage testing, the outcome of the particle impingement experiments of the single-reinforced alloys indicates reducing RL for increasing impingement angle (IA). IA effect is more noticeable between 8° rotated and 16° rotated positions of the specimens. This finding is consistent with what might be predicted from literature on solid-particle erosion of brittle materials, but the coarse-particle, medium-velocity impingement abrasion conditions produced by the ICAT are very different from those of erosion tests.
Hence this finding was not readily predictable, and represents important understanding for the factors controlling performance in ore chute liners. 33 dual-reinforced alloys are put through the same testing regime applied to the single-reinforced alloys. The basalt tests suggest that dual reinforcement stops the RL reversal phenomenon observed in high CVF single-reinforced alloys, but provides no extra benefit over the single reinforcement for low CVF alloys. The greywacke and granite experiments suggest modest benefits over the single reinforcement for hypoeutectic alloys.
Coarse-particle abrasion performance of the dual-reinforced alloys (relative to steel) is marginally better than their fine-particle performance. However, dual-reinforcement shows no benefit over single-reinforcement in the coarse-particle tests. Impingement angle test performance of dual reinforced alloys compared to that of the single-reinforced alloys is better for near-tangential sliding (0–12°) and for small tilt angles (8–20°).
However, at the higher tilt angle, giving impingement at 16–28°, dual-reinforced alloys seem to get adversely affected more than the single-reinforced counterparts, so that they under-perform.SEM examination of the worn surfaces indicated broad similarity in wear mechanisms between the different testing conditions.
However, even though the visible differences were not dramatic, it could be inferred that the above-described conditions leading to the RL reversal phenomenon must act by deeply eroding the matrix, removing support from the carbides, which then suffered increased tendency for micro-fracture, which in turn makes them less able to protect the matrix.Dual-reinforced HCWCI shows promising wear performance advantages for some wear conditions over the single-reinforced counterparts, but not for all conditions.
Open the resolved locator · 10.14264/ebbeea7
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)