go-v.orgdoi

The Conduct of Public Inquiries: Law, Policy, and Practice (review)

Gregory J. Inwood · Canadian Public Policy · 2010

  • DOI 10.1353/cpp.2010.0019
  • Publisher University of Toronto Press
  • Type book-review
  • Issued 2010

Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.

Canadian Public Policy · University of Toronto Press · book-review · 2010

Abstract

Reviewed by: The Conduct of Public Inquiries: Law, Policy, and Practice Gregory J. Inwood The Conduct of Public Inquiries: Law, Policy, and Practice by Ed Ratushny. Toronto: Irwin Law, 2009. In 1867, Walter Bagehot observed that “the great maxim of modern thought is not only the toleration of everything but the examination of everything.” [End Page 538] This perhaps explains the propensity in Canada to hold public inquiries. Given their numbers, brave is the academic who takes on their study. There have been so many of such varying nature that focusing on a single inquiry is daunting enough, let alone undertaking a comparative analysis of dozens.

Ed Ratushny has been brave—and successful—in producing an important, useful, and broad-ranging analysis of these “residual institutions,” as he calls them. He drills down very deeply into the workings of public inquiries and displays a unique depth and breadth of knowledge. Indeed, it is doubtful if anyone in this country knows so much about so many public inquiries, and we learn a great deal from this ambitious overview. Ratushny does an exemplary job in the opening two chapters of introducing the topic and setting the stage for further analysis.

He includes a handy set of tables indicating authorizing statutes for inquiries in different Canadian jurisdictions and summarizing the 40 inquiries that receive his attention. Ratushny notes the usual taxonomies of inquiries as either policy/advisory or investigative, but goes further by parsing the investigative types. He also importantly points out in many examples how policy/advisory and investigative inquiries often overlap.

Ratushny presents a most useful analysis of various bodies which, while not usually considered in the literature, are nonetheless important instruments alongside the traditionally understood meaning of “public inquiries.” Thus he comments comparatively on wrongful-conviction inquiries, inquiries investigating crimes, and other ongoing inquiry bodies as well as alternative processes like legislative committees, criminal investigations, existing statutory processes, departmental investigations, and informal inquiries. This is a real strength of the book.

In addition, Ratushny usefully canvasses significant elements of public inquiries in well-laid-out chapters on how they are established, the role of commissioners and counsel, their legal framework, the conduct of hearings, and the final report. These chapters contain considerable detail and insight of great value, and are interspersed with practical commentary on the “how-to” aspects of running a successful inquiry. One organizational issue that might have deepened the comparative value of the analysis would have been to integrate Chapter 10 on policy/advisory inquiries into the other chapters on investigative inquires, rather than have it stand alone.

As is, it feels a bit like an add-on that peters out with a brief discussion of truth and reconciliation commissions. A more substantive concluding chapter might have tied together key themes and findings. The literature on public inquiries needs to address a fundamental question: What is their role in policy change? As Ratushny correctly asserts, policy considerations arise out of both policy/advisory and investigative inquiries. What are the conditions under which a public inquiry brings about policy change? Are there certain key variables that explain the influence of these bodies which, after all, have no power to implement their recommendations? Is it leadership?

Is it political conditions? Is it the care with which the terms of reference set out the scope of the inquiry? Is it astute commission counsel? Is it the weight of public evidence or the quality of research by the inquiry? Further, one could ask, What key ideational factors explain the role of public inquires in policy change? What institutional factors explain their role—does there have to be a failure in the executive, legislative, and/or judicial branches to create the space for public inquiries? What about the role of key actors, both in the state and society?

And finally, what is the nature of relations that affect the ability of the inquiry to effect policy change, both inside and outside the inquiry? These questions occur explicitly or implicitly in Ratushny’s dense analysis, although not necessarily [End Page 539] systematically. Thus, for example, he provides a detailed assessment of the personality and leadership of a certain commission chair in one account...

Open the resolved locator · 10.1353/cpp.2010.0019

Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)

Registry
OpenAlex DOI index + API
Fetched
2026-11-20 00:40 UTC
Cache state
not cached yet (bulk-index+openalex)
Locator
https://muse.jhu.edu/verify
Metadata licence
OpenAlex metadata (CC0)
Scope
Metadata as returned by the resolver; abstracts are never generated here.