Power without Law: The Supreme Court of Canada, the Marshall Decisions, and the Failure of Judicial Activism (review)
Andrew Nurse · Canadian Public Policy · 2010
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
Canadian Public Policy · University of Toronto Press · book-review · 2010
Abstract
Reviewed by: Power without Law: The Supreme Court of Canada, the Marshall Decisions, and the Failure of Judicial Activism Andrew Nurse Power without Law: The Supreme Court of Canada, the Marshall Decisions, and the Failure of Judicial Activism by Alex M. Cameron. Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2009. Alex M. Cameron wrote Power without Law to correct what he views as the Supreme Court of Canada’s (SCC) fundamental mistake of recognizing the legitimacy of aboriginal treaty rights in R v. Marshall (1999).
According to Cameron, the court erred in just about every way possible: it misconstrued history, used faulty interpretive methods, overextended its authority, and violated basic judicial and constitutional principles. The result, Cameron contends, was a judicial rewriting of history in support of treaty rights that, in his view, do not exist. The political and social implications were grave. Cameron contends that the Marshall decision fractured the peace of communities (leading to, among other things, rioting), placed the environment at risk, subverted democracy, and ultimately wasted millions of dollars in taxpayers’ money while destroying long-standing regulatory regimes.
On a broader level, Power without Law is an intervention into debates surrounding judicial review, its proper sphere, and its justifiable limits. Cameron concludes that the courts should not involve themselves in policy matters, leaving these to sovereign legislatures guided by long-established constitutional principles. The recognition of treaty rights in the Maritimes is, in his view, a case in point. Power without Law is written in a tone of respect and in a spirit of reasoned dialogue. I appreciate its commitment to nuanced, principled, and careful consideration of important public issues and will address this text in the same spirit.
I make this point because one should not mistake Cameron for a right-wing anti-Native ideologue, but from my perspective as an historian, I find that his arguments are deeply flawed as both scholarship and policy. There are several different orders of mistakes to note. First, the author argues that the SCC erred in R v. Marshall because it ignored or invented history. Yet, the author’s own analytic methods fracture the basic rules of historical investigation. For instance, he does not appear to have done any archival research. His references to primary documents are taken entirely from court proceedings and so he assesses the documentary evidence outside its archival context.
Said differently, he appears to mine individual archival sources selected by someone else for what they can say in support of his interpretation, instead of drawing conclusions from the totality of primary sources. The author appears unaware of key secondary sources on his subject. He makes no effort to set his narrative in the context of early colonial Maritime history or the development of the northeastern frontier, but instead focuses on the history of British constitutional principles (and, again, appears unaware of key sources).
Cameron sustains his interpretation, at one point, using post hoc reasoning; he makes no effort to understand the meaning of language in its context, but instead appears to assume that what words mean today is exactly what they meant in the eighteenth century, the most unfortunate of which is his assumption that the word “submission” meant “surrender.” Combined, these mistakes lead the author to an interpretation of Maritime history that is, frankly, unrecognizable to anyone who has studied Maritime history. Second, other conclusions the author draws are based on the same flawed interpretive methods.
For example, he concludes that there were no conflicts between Native and non-Native communities in Maritime Canada before the Marshall Decision. Yet, no references and no evidence sustain this contention. If he were to ask members of Native communities exactly how peaceful their pre-Marshall lives were, what would be their response? We do not know because Cameron did not ask. He simply assumed all was well and then assumed that an assessment he made on the basis of no evidence was true. In another instance, Cameron confuses technology with culture and in still another comes very close to arguing that authentic Native culture is incompatible with modernity.
What is interesting [End Page 130] is that all of these flawed interpretations seem to involve a...
Open the resolved locator · 10.1353/cpp.0.0055
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)