The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better (review)
Emily Maddocks · Canadian Public Policy · 2010
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
Canadian Public Policy · University of Toronto Press · article · 2010
Abstract
Reviewed by: The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better Emily Maddocks The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better by Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett. London: Penguin Books, 2009. The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better is a landmark reference on the health of populations. This new book by Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett catalogues the accumulated research on income inequality. The premise of The Spirit Level is that well-being is patterned on something other than individual wealth. Rather, physical and social health is spread among particular groups according to a recurring pattern—that of income inequality.
Where there are bigger differences in the distribution of wealth, undesirable health and social outcomes are more prevalent. Wilkinson and Pickett characterize income inequality in two ways. In analyses comparing “rich countries,” income inequality is the ratio between the average household income of the richest 20 percent and that of the poorest 20 percent; in the comparisons of US states, income inequality is measured using the Gini coefficient. The authors illustrate their argument regarding the importance of income inequality using ten different indicators of health and social well-being.
According to this model, addressing a common determinant addresses the roots of multiple forms of disadvantage; by reducing income inequality, a society can reduce the incidence and prevalence of various social problems. In the book, the US and the UK are the most common examples as they are among the most unequal of unequal societies. Albeit to a lesser extent than in these other countries, income inequality is a growing concern in Canada; recent research has shown that income inequality in Canada increased between 1990 and 2000 (Picot and Myles 2005, 9). The implication is that income inequality is affecting individual and community well-being—the spirit level—in our society too.
Because of the breadth of the topic and the diverse nature of the intended audience, the authors have necessarily abridged the research. The result is an accessible reader on what is known about income inequality. This accessibility is necessary for the stated goal of The Spirit Level. Wilkinson and Pickett have assumed the task of raising awareness about this body of evidence. They are convinced [End Page 133] that raising awareness is a key stage in a process of change—that the evidence exists to be shared, and that informed actors are empowered actors.
In describing their purpose, Wilkinson and Pickett engage the discourse of political action; they name the political nature of their goal and, in so doing, reinforce the strength of their contribution. In the face of all the evidence about problems that reduce quality of life, the narrative reflects a spirited can-do, even must-do, attitude toward reducing inequality: “Far from being inevitable and unstoppable, the sense of deterioration in social wellbeing and the quality of social relations in society is reversible. Understanding the effects of inequality means that we suddenly have a policy handle on the wellbeing of whole societies” (p. 33).
Yet, without disparaging either the inspiring tone or the important connection to official policy action, the references to action are ambiguous and somewhat superficial. Based on the accumulated evidence, income inequality is, indeed, a focus for policy at multiple levels and by myriad actors. To “suddenly” have a “handle” on this issue, however, would require substantial additional information about successful interventions. And while it is useful to know that the level of trust is low where inequality is high, perhaps the more actionable analysis would be to examine where the level of trust is high and then ask why and how.
Admittedly, these details are beyond the scope of an overview text like The Spirit Level. In the preface to their text, Wilkinson and Pickett propose Evidence-Based Politics as an alternate title. “At this stage,” they explain, “creating the political will to make society more equal is more important than pinning our colours to a particular set of policies to reduce inequality. Political will is dependent on the development of a vision of a better society which is both achievable and inspiring” (p. 264). The idea is that people will respond to...
Open the resolved locator · 10.1353/cpp.0.0049
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)