To Send a Shiver through Unitel: Imperial Philosophy and the Resistant Word in Paul Muldoon's "Madoc--A Mystery"
Andrew J. Auge · Contemporary Literature · 2005
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
Contemporary Literature · University of Wisconsin Press · article · 2005
Abstract
1 In his Clarendon Lectures at Oxford in 1998, Paul Muldoon postulated that the Irish literary tradition is characterized by its "valorization of obliquity and tangentiality" and its concomitant "disregard for the line between sense and nonsense" and "linear narrative" (To Ireland 107). Few works in that tradition exemplify these distinguishing characteristics more fully than Muldoon's own long poem "Madoc—A Mystery."1 Muldoon's bizarre masterpiece interfuses the collagist style of modernist epics such as William Carlos Williams's Paterson and T. S.
Eliot's The Waste Land with the parodic spirit of anti-epics such as Lord Byron's Don Juan.
It incorporates such disparate materials as snippets from the poetry, journals, and letters of the Romantic poets Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Robert Southey, Thomas Moore, and Byron; extended passages from the journals of the American explorers Meriwether Lewis and William Clark, and shorter ones from the journals of George Catlin, the American painter of western indigenes; and speeches from Native American chieftains, such as the Seneca leader Red Jacket, a time line of the biography of the [End Page 636] Mohawk warrior-chief Thayendanegea (also known as Joseph Brant), and retellings of Seneca myths.
All of this heterogeneous material is gathered together in a desultory narrative structure that interweaves an imagined account of the Pantisocracy, the utopian community that Coleridge and Southey envisioned creating in early nineteenth-century America, with more truncated descriptions of the Lewis and Clark expedition, Aaron Burr's quarrel with Alexander Hamilton and his subsequent short-lived rebellion, and the struggles of the Iroquois in the face of the assimilationist pressures of the new American republic.
The incongruous associations evoked by this narrative bricolage clearly work together to deflate the epic pretensions of the various Anglo-American imperial enterprises, real and imagined, alluded to in the poem. What is less apparent and more interesting is the way in which seemingly extraneous features of this strange text—its frame narrative and subtitles—deepen the poem's critique of imperialism by locating it within the context of the age-old quarrel between philosophy and poetry.
By directing its ludic energy against the totalizing aspirations of reason, Muldoon's poem enacts, as John Goodby puts it, "a savage critique of Western imperialism and its metaphysical foundations" (299).2 Muldoon's counterstrike against these hegemonic forces occurs through "Madoc"'s linguistic jouissance, its capacity, as the poem itself puts it, to "winkle" the "'semen' out of 'semantics'"—to set forth a process of dissemination that releases words and things from the control of the imperial mind (222).3 [End Page 637] The poem's frame narrative begins and ends with a bizarre account of the imprisonment of a character named South within a totalitarian, futuristic state, "Unitel" (15) or "Unitel West" (259), and all of its intervening narrative episodes are presented as emanating from a malign instrument, a "retinagraph," attached to the back of South's eyeball (18).
Muldoon's embedding of the account of the Pantisocracy and other colonial enterprises within the oppressive domain of Unitel West is a telling hermeneutic gesture, one that places modern colonialism within the purview of a larger cultural and historical phenomenon—the totalizing (uni) master narrative (tel) of the West. The fact that the poem's 233 subsections are each titled after a Western thinker, beginning with the pre-Socratic philosopher Thales and concluding with the contemporary physicist Stephen Hawking, identifies this master narrative with the rise of philosophical and scientific rationality that is the definitive achievement of Western culture.
These subtitles are generally regarded as little more than a jeu d'esprit. Muldoon himself seems dismissive of them, comparing them to scaffolding left up after the building has been completed ("Interview" 14). But as Muldoon no doubt realized, much of the pleasure in reading "Madoc—A...
Open the resolved locator · 10.1353/cli.2006.0001
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)