Transpositions
— · Leuven University Press eBooks · 2018
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
Leuven University Press eBooks · Leuven University Press · book · 2018
Abstract
multiple logic of transposition complicates our episteme, allowing more complex phenomena to emerge that cannot be traced formally.The methodologies, epistemologies, and aesthetics that have been developed under the umbrella of "artistic research," in particular under transdisciplinary conditions, may offer relevant resources in order to productively engage such complications.At its limits this leads to more radical understandings of existent definitions of "transposition," suspending given orders in favour of orders emergent from materially situated, concrete operations at hand in a practice lending a more speculative dimension to an otherwise merely functional concept.This book accepts the resulting radicalisation of the concept of "transposition," and by carrying "artistic research" in its subtitle suggests that artistic research may be a context in which seemingly functional concepts can gain a new lease of life as new potentials become emphasised.Such work on concepts is not without a precursor.In my previous book in this series, Experimental Systems: Future Knowledge in Artistic Research (Schwab 2013a), for instance, I proposed a more coherent use of Hans-Jörg Rheinberger's term "experimental system" in the context of artistic research, made possible by Rheinberger's work to complicate everyday notions of "experimental system" as they are used by practitioners and not observers (Rheinberger 1997, 19).Practitioners, according to this assumption, use concepts differently-not as foundations for a theory to be confirmed, but as operational "scarcely imaginable basic concepts" (Rheinberger, ibid., here quoting Freud) that drive knowledge for as long as they are productive.Such practitioners' concepts have the potential to exceed their status as "technical objects" and become "epistemic things."While the former are needed in a research environment to create stable conditions, the latter are what is epistemically underdetermined and, thus, able to develop into future knowledge.As Rheinberger suggests, a certain amount of deconstructive labour is needed not so much to deploy such concepts as those practitioners do but to articulate them together with their characteristic fuzziness or "epistemic noise," as Cecile Malaspina (2014), one of the authors of the present volume, might describe it.The same is true, to introduce a second example, of Catherine Malabou's work on the brain, where with "plasticity" she comes across a concept central to neuroscience-"we run into this word in every neurology department of every medical school and of every university hospital" (Malabou 2008, 4).Yet, despite the ubiquity of the concept, she argues that through a confusion with notions of "flexibility" it had not been realised that "the brain is not already made" (ibid., 7) and that not only neuroscience but all aspects of culture are part of a process of formation outside which nothing is given.Like "experimental system," "plasticity" may be a concept readily used to describe the crucial, productive part of a system that awaits complication.As such concepts are taken on, new potentials are realised not determined by what we believe them to mean.This includes new possibilities for action-now, however, not in control of a phenomenon but deeply implied.As these examples from non-artistic disciplines illustrate, when referring to the relevance of artistic research for such operations, the suggestion is not From an orthodox perspective these more extreme transpositions may be dubious since seen from afar it looks like anything could be a non-site/transposition given that little in it resembled its original appearance-as if a photograph taken of a house showed a tree, or a cow, or a bag . . .and we'd be fine with it.For contemporary art, though, hinted at here with reference to Smithson, "anything goes" is not a threat but a liberation, but only if the specificity of a particular transposition is respected: while in theory all could be possible, in practice, we are given very concrete propositions understandable in their transpositionality only from within a concrete logic spread out across the transposition.This logic is immanent and not transferable-only perhaps as its transposition into a new piece.Putting forward Smithson's Non-Sites as an example suggests that such transpositional operations are at least relevant for contemporary art, although it would require further research to establish precisely how relevant they are.Personally, I would speculate that notions implied by contemporary art, such as "post-medium" or "post-conceptual" require at least some degree of transpositionality to work, since in both cases contemporary art aspires to exceed external frames of reference (medium/concept) while operating according to a more complex, often open logic.by the artists or an audience, but must be the self-reflection of art itself where the new constellation performs, evidences, or exposed something that could otherwise not be had.In "Ineffable Dispositions," Mika Elo looks at what he calls the "artistic research syndrome" through the wider perspective of shifting cultural techniques as analysed by Sybille Krämer and Horst Bredekamp.Rather than understanding "syndrome" as expressing pathologies, Elo uses it to emphasise that there is no single symptom and that each analysis and, hence, diagnoses can give only a partial view.Focusing on writing as transpositional activity and referring to Walter Benjamin, Elo seeks a "magical" mode of writing for artistic research that does not instrumentalise art remaining sensitive to a medium's * This chapter was first published in Rosi Braidotti, Transpositions: On Nomadic Ethics (Cambridge:
Open the resolved locator · 10.1353/book.109369
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)