go-v.orgdoi

What Place Ethics?

Fiona Alice Miller · Healthcare Quarterly · 2000

  • DOI 10.12927/hcq..16700
  • Publisher Longwoods Publishing
  • Type article
  • Issued 2000

Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.

Healthcare Quarterly · Longwoods Publishing · article · 2000

Abstract

term “bioethics” was coined in 1971. Yet despite this brief history, bioethics has achieved remarkable public and institutional visibility. Most activities within healthcare, including research, clinical practice and institutional organization, are profoundly influenced by ethical deliberation. Margaret Somerville is a well-known advocate of such “ethics talk.” The founding Director of the Centre for Medicine, Ethics and Law at McGill University, Somerville views ‘ethics talk’ as a source for the communal solidarity and collective values that seem otherwise impracticable in our diverse, secular and hyperactive world. For Somerville, healthcare is a privileged arena for such talk.

Healthcare is, as she puts it, an “ethics laboratory” (pg. 4). In the face of profound new technologies, a growing individualist ethos, and a public conversation structured by the media and thus obsessed with compelling individual instances to the detriment of collective concerns, those who work in healthcare are obliged to do ethics. To date, much of Somerville’s work has been published in academic monographs, as conference or commission reports, and in commentary on selected topics in the popular media.

The Ethical Canary thus provides a welcome opportunity for readers to gain access to a full range of her ethical deliberations, and to assess whether the “ethical toolbox” that Somerville describes can serve to illuminate and guide practice. The “ethical canary” is Somerville’s chosen metaphor. Where the canary of old demonstrated the safety of coalmines through its survival, the ethical canary identifies ethical minefields through investigation. Somerville considers a range of such minefields in her book, each of which occupies a chapter.

The first part of The Ethical Canary is devoted to an exploration of several new, sometimes speculative, technologies – assisted conception, human cloning and xenotransplantation. The ethical quandaries that Somerville identifies are the classic ones: the need to balance an individual’s perception of potential gain with the broader social and metaphysical hazards such practices might produce. Not all that science can do should be done, Somerville argues: ethical progress must form an ongoing complement to scientific progress. Yet a balance is decidedly hard to achieve.

In the case of assisted conception and reproductive cloning, attention to the rights of the child (potential or actual) provides some resource for Somerville in enjoining scientific restraint. In the case of therapeutic cloning or xenotransplantation, however, ethical principles provide uncertain guidance for how to decide. The next set of chapters elevate the discussion from the fact of ethical conflict, to the process by which it is engaged. Somerville addresses complex medical and social decisionmaking involving euthanasia, non-consensual termination of life support, overruling parents in decision-making about their children’s treatment, and the ethics of non-therapeutic Book Review

Open the resolved locator · 10.12927/hcq..16700

Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)