Members Only? Why Associational Autonomy Cannot Justify Closing State Borders
David V. Axelsen · The Journal of Politics · 2024
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
The Journal of Politics · University of Chicago Press · article · 2024
Abstract
It is usually assumed that states have a right to exclude immigrants. Defenders of the Associational View argue that states are justified in closing their borders to immigrants because having the right to exclude is necessary for members to be able to control the character of their association. It is necessary to protect associational autonomy. Unlike in a domestic setting, however, individuals lack several other key components of associational autonomy internationally. On this background, therefore, it is not clear that the right to exclude better protects associational autonomy than its absence.
I explore three potential solutions to this problem, drawn from contemporary versions of the Associational View. The three solutions fall short since, ultimately, they do not provide sound justifications for the unilateral right to exclude migrants. Building on this discussion, I set out some institutional elements that should be present in a well-conceived instantiation of associational autonomy.
Open the resolved locator · 10.1086/730751
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)