Hewers of Wood, Drawers of Gall: The Wooden Economies of Race inTitus AndronicusandLust’s Dominion
William H. Steffen · Renaissance Drama · 2020
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
Renaissance Drama · Northwestern University Press · article · 2020
Abstract
Previous articleNext article FreeHewers of Wood, Drawers of Gall: The Wooden Economies of Race in Titus Andronicus and Lust's DominionWilliam SteffenWilliam SteffenAmerican International College, USA Search for more articles by this author Full TextPDF Add to favoritesDownload CitationTrack CitationsPermissionsReprints Share onFacebookTwitterLinked InRedditEmailQR Code SectionsMoreAnd the princes said unto them [the Gibeonites], Let them live; but let them be hewers of wood and drawers of water unto all the congregation.—Joshua 9:21, AVIn the opening scene of Titus Andronicus (ca.
1594), the victorious Andronicus clan demands that the Goth queen's eldest son, Alarbus, be seized, "That we may hew his limbs and on a pile, / Ad manes fratrum, sacrifice his flesh / Before this earthly prison" (1.1.100–102; emphasis added).1 When Tamora's plea for mercy fails to assuage her captors, Lucius orders his brothers to "make a fire straight, / And with our swords upon a pile of wood / Let's hew his limbs till they be clean consumed" (1.1.130–32; emphasis added).
When the Andronicus sons return a few moments later, Lucius draws attention to the offstage spectacle of smoke rising in the air:See, lord and father, how we have performedOur Roman rites. Alarbus' limbs are lopped,And entrails feed the sacrificing fireWhose smoke like incense doth perfume the sky.(1.1.145–48)Shakespeare's first revenge tragedy repeatedly conflates the hewing and consumption of bodies with the hewing and consumption of wood. The Romans characterize Alarbus's arms and legs in wooden terms; his "limbs" will add fuel to an already hewn "pile of wood," but not before they are "lopped" like branches from a tree.
The Romans, however, are not the only ones to "hew" human limbs in this play. Aaron the Moor lends a hand in severing the hand of Titus, and Chiron and Demetrius, the licentious siblings of the fragmented Alarbus, later avenge their brother's death by raping and dismembering Titus's only daughter, Lavinia. Upon beholding her ravished body, Lavinia's uncle Marcus asks, "What stern ungentle hands / Hath lopped and hewed and made thy body bare / Of her two branches?" (2.4.16–18; emphasis added).
In addition to calling attention to his niece's disfigured body, Marcus's metaphor conflates the violence of cutting off her hands with the excessive hewing and consumption of trees.Marcus's metaphor may have struck a chord with his Elizabethan audience, who were in the throes of a devastating wood shortage. As a result of overconsumption, timber prices more than tripled between 1500 and 1600.2 Early modern England was heavily dependent on wood for fuel, building materials, and (among other things) theatrical properties.
As Vin Nardizzi has shown, the woodenness of the nine theaters built in London between 1567 and 1614 underscored the theater's complicity in the ecological crisis, informing several plays that indulged an "array of eco-fantasies and nightmares about the shortage of wood."3Titus was by no means the only play to evoke the timber crisis onstage. But what is unique about the ecological "nightmare" of Titus is the way it offers a suggestive link between the destruction of wooden timber, brutal violence against humans, and emerging racial discourses.This material and linguistic link juxtaposes two different kinds of "hewn" bodies in the play.
Alarbus, Lavinia, and Titus lose their limbs in a literal way, although the play measures the weight of this loss through their metaphorical comparison to a shorn, limbless, woody plant. At the same time, the verb "hew" (used three times in this play) operates ambiguously in relation to Aaron's black "hue" (a noun used eight times in the play).4 The linguistic and material interaction between the play's hews and hues fosters a connection between environmentally destructive labor and the emergent racialization of African bodies.
In the sixteenth century, Christian Europeans had already begun to use the scriptural "curse of Ham," Noah's declaration that Ham's son Canaan and his descendants shall be "servant[s] of servants," to link black skin with enslavement.5 By the eighteenth century, the curse of Ham and the punitive condemnation of the Gibeonites to be "hewers of wood and drawers of water" became the most popular justifications for enslaving Africans on the basis of race.6 By the nineteenth century, the epithet "hewers of wood and drawers of water" named a racialized workforce enslaved by terror, whose labor was "necessary to the growth of capitalism."7 But in the sixteenth century, this link between racialization and the damaging environmental labor of "hewing" was still emerging.
Through the violence it stages against a dual human and environmental body, facilitated by the homophonic slippage between "hew" and "hue," Shakespeare's play reveals how early material constructions of African Moors both generated and reflected signs of environmental degradation.Below, I offer further insight into the link between the theatrical construction of protoracial difference and environmental degradation by showing how the stage's physical materials for representing African Moors relied on the exploitation of European and colonial environments.
Two plays in particular, Titus Andronicus and Thomas Dekker's Lust's Dominion (1600), each written during the height of the timber crisis in Elizabethan England, depend on physical and linguistic technologies to connect the materials used to represent the black skin of African Moors onstage with their ecological and social price tags.8 By focusing on the imported wooden ingredients that constituted the black skin worn by the White actors who played Aaron and Eleazar—Moors who have been both reduced by critics to racist representations of dark-hearted villains and, at the same time, admired for their rhetoric and intelligence—I investigate how the materials of the stage may have mediated early modern representations and interpretations of emergent racial categories.9 Through reorienting our understanding of Aaron and Eleazar around the wooden commodities that may have constituted their black skin in performance—namely, cork and galls—I hope to show how natural commodities dictate and influence an emergent racial discourse on the English stage.The contemporary demand for foreign galls reframes our understanding of nature's role in representing Moors like Eleazar and Aaron on the English stage.
Galls, as early modern playwrights would have known, were common ingredients in both ink and blackface cosmetic recipes of the period. Eleazar and Aaron are two of several Moors of the English stage whose black skin associates them with a discursive deception, such as forgery or the dissemination of print.10 Eleazar issues and distributes printed texts in order to gain leverage and power, and Aaron forges a letter to frame the Andronicii for a crime they did not commit.
Eleazar even hints at the material technology responsible for his black skin when he refuses to "digest this Gall" (Lust's Dominion 1.2.163) of banishment and hopes that his revenge on Cardinal Mendoza for "this disgrace, / Shall dye [his] soule, as Inky as my face" (1.2.190–91). Punning on the material and humoral associations of "gall," Eleazar betrays an anxiety about how his audience will read or interpret his black body—his "inky" face.
By calling attention to galls as a potential material ingredient in his own complexion, Eleazar invites audiences to reflect on the metonymic association between the specific provenance of galls and the Moor he embodies onstage. Eleazar's pun also links his dark skin to the utilities and assumptions associated with imported galls in early modern England. But whereas imported Aleppo galls were valued for yielding a more permanent and endurable ink on paper, the potential use of galls in performance produces the opposite effect when signifying black skin on stage. When worn by an actor playing a Moor, galls mediate the meaning of black skin.
Aaron and Eleazar may attempt to use ink to assert a single dominating narrative about themselves, but they also undermine those narratives and open them to an expansive array of environmental, social, political, and humoral connotations.Galls were not the only wooden commodities used in blackface cosmetics on the early modern stage. Cork wood, which did not grow in England and which had been regularly imported to England from Portugal before the English trade embargo with the Iberian Peninsula, was also likely used to represent Moors on stage and similarly reinforces a metonymic association between populations of Moors and the materials used to represent them.
If cork was used to represent Aaron's black skin on stage, then the play's discursive "hues" and "hews" might operate in a similar fashion to Eleazar's "gall" by linking black skin with a specific provenance of cork—Portugal—with a significant population of Moors. Aaron's pun ties his black "hue" not only to the violent hewing he orchestrates against the Romans but also to the material and environmental hewing that a White actor playing a Moor likely required for a cosmetic paint made of wooden ingredients.
The theatricality of Aaron's false black skin showcases his control in managing his own representation at the same time that it operates as a racist justification for his villainy. Aaron and Eleazar each potentially exploit the materials that might compose their dark skin.
Aaron's manipulation of the woods outside of Rome situates him in a complicated relationship with the natural world, which is akin to Eleazar's relationship with galls and his manipulation of print.A growing body of research emphasizes how the emergent status of "race" in the early modern period coalesced with the emergent status of the "human," which was ontologically indistinct from the natural world.11 But in Titus Andronicus, Aaron embodies the fluid complexity of these emerging racial and ecological discourses.
Aaron is aligned with the nonhuman natural world not only because he is defined by the hues (and hews) required to darken his complexion before a given performance; he also vows to live as a single father on what nature provides. However, Aaron is a true husbandman, a master at manipulating and exploiting his environments to gain his revenge. Aaron is also routinely positioned as an Other in Rome by the Andronicii, even though he is arguably the play's best father and displays his most honest self before he is planted in the earth.
Aaron's proximity to the natural world and his complex relationship with it showcases the degree to which a modern racial ideology relies on environmental violence. The modern concept of racial difference cannot be apprehended within an ontological framework where humans and nature are indistinct. The material representation of Aaron and Eleazar both facilitates and exposes the environmental violence necessary to bring cork, galls, (and by extension) stage Moors to England.
Aaron's ambiguous relationship to nature is comparable to Eleazar's ambiguous relationship with print because of how both Moors deliberately exploit the wooden commodities on which their theatrical representation potentially depends. Their wordplay only further catalyzes the discursive and environmental violence that (according to these plays) must accompany the formation of a racial discourse.
A hierarchy of one group of humans over another cannot exist without the damage dealt by these puns, which conflate the hued skin of Moors with a tree's hewn limbs, humoral gall with imported galls, and Black characters of the stage with black characters of the page.Cork and Moors on the Early Modern StageAlthough "race" bore a different connotation in early modern England than it does today, markers of racialized difference were already emerging.
Scholars have shown that early modern racial categories were rarely fully signified by skin color and often conflated or intersected with gender, nationality, religion, class or nobility, and even political affiliation.12 But whereas most scholars discuss race as a deliberate and discursive social construction which justifies patriarchal, colonial, or class oppression, I believe we have more to gain by asking not what race is for but, rather, what are the materials race uses?13 Cork is one substance whose use in blackface cosmetics may have issued some important consequences for the racial discourse emerging in the sixteenth century.
For example, if cork was used by White actors to play Moors, it likely fashioned an associative link between the Moor character and the specific provenance from which cork derived. Furthermore, cork also may have created an association on the stage between Moor characters and the specific uses to which these materials were put in English culture, which included enterprises linked to expanding trade and the
Open the resolved locator · 10.1086/712101
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)