The External Evidence of the Exodus
Nathaniel Schmidt · Hebraica · 1894
Not cached yet. This record was fetched live for this request and is stored after the lookup. Reopening the page should serve the cached copy.
Hebraica · University of Chicago Press · article · 1894
Abstract
According to the Elohist, the Sons of Israel lived for three or four generationsl among the Egyptians,2 honored and supported at first,3 but subsequently enslaved and ill treated.4From this oppression they were delivered through Moses, who with the rod of Gods smote the land of Egypt with five great plagues, viz.: blood in the river,6 hail,7 locusts,s darkness9 and disease,lo then divided the waters of the Yam Suph,11 caused the people to march through the sea, fought 'Amalek at Rephidim,12 continued to Hioreb, the mount of God,a13 received Yithro, the priest of Midyan,14 settled at Kadel and planned the conquest of the Amorite kingdom of Sil.on.15The Yahwist related that Israel once resided with flocks and herds in the province of Gogen16 and grew to be a great and mighty nation, feared by the Egyptians, who therefore forced them to supply brick and laborers for the building of the store-cities of Pithom and Ramses.17Yahweh, 1 Gen.
L. 23; Ex.II. 1. 2 Bacon seems to me correct in his view that in this document "we see the Hebrews still a mere clan quietly living in one of the cities of Egypt, the royal city, and scattered as individuals among the Egyptians' dwellings," JBL., X., 1891, p. 110.How, with his fine appreciation of E's consistency, Bacon can assign to him Ex.xuI.37b, Num.xI.21, I cannot quite understand."Slaves, not in a condition to own flocks and herds and crops" are scarcely in a position to "go forth like an army 600,000 strong, armed and with an high hand," JBL., IX., 1890, p. 93.With Kittel, Geschichte, p. 196, I assign these passages to P.
Cf. also Addis, The Oldest Book of Hebrew History, 1893, p. 127. 3 Gen.XLVII.12. 4 Ex.I. 1 sqq.5 Ex.Iv. 17, 20b aL.6 Ex.vII.15, 17b, 20b, 23.SEx.ix.22, 23a, 25a.8 Ex.x. 12, 13aa, 14aa, 15ap.9 Ex.x. 20-23.27. 10 The order in E was probably as follows: xI.1-3; xiI.35, 36; this sentence 7 l ••1f 1K'1 D'~YD Y y ; then xII.30a/b, 31a, 33 and 38a.For "3" and the construction of J7D, cf.Ex.V. 3 (vs.1-4 belong to E). 11 Ex.xIII.18. 12 Ex.xvII.8-16.13 EX.XIX. 26. 14 Ex.XVIII, 1. 15 Num.xxL.21-31.16 All references to Gogen and to flocks and herds belong to J.
On this important point I agree entirely with Bacon, L. c.A list in the temple atDenderah designates Kesem as the capital of the twentieth nome in Lower Egypt, called Sopt, Diimichen, Rec., III., 65, 20.It is probable that LX. had this in mind in rendering reaeis.Ptolemy calls the capital of Apaftag vo/iog, 4atovaa, and with this agrees the Coptic Fakos=pa Kos, the modern Tell Falpus.The name was, no doubt, extended from the city to the nomos in the form of Kos or Kosem.Cf.Diimichen, Geographie d. alten Aegyptens, 1887, p. 265; also Ebers in Riehm, Handwarterbueh, 1893-1894.If this identification is correct, the Gogen of Josh.x.
41; xI.16, D2. can scarcely be the same as the Golen of J, as Bacon thinks, 1. c.It may be a fertile strip of land west of the Negeb named after the Egyptian province; and the city of the same name, Josh.xv.51, its capital.17 Ex.I. 11, Pi Tum, "the abode of Tum," was the sacred name of the capital of Abnefer, the VIIIth nome in Lower Egypt, its civil name being Thukut = ~130, Ex. xI.37a P. It was situated in the Wadi Tumilat where the modern Tell el Maskhuta is; of.Naville, The Store-City of Pithom,* 1888.Ramses has not yet been identified.
Open the resolved locator · 10.1086/369186
Metadata licence: OpenAlex metadata (CC0)